问题是找到具有给定约束的有效序列(A1,A2....AN)的数目:
我只能想到一个回溯解决方案,其中每个递归调用都会对给定的Ai位置尝试从1到6的所有数字。
这看起来更像是蛮力的方式。你能帮我找到一个最佳的解决方案吗。
发布于 2022-04-07 07:45:52
我们可以利用这样一个事实,即只有6个可能的数字可以用来构造数字。
dp[i][j][k],它基本上是count of i-digit numbers with the i-th digit as j, (i-1)th digit as k。{2: [1,3,5], 3: [1,2,4,5], 6: [1,5]}...dp[0] = 0 for all j,k,dp[1] = 0 for all j,k,dp[2][j][k] = 1 if gcd(j,k)==1 and j!=kfor i in range 2 to n:
for j in range 1 to 6:
for k in range 1 to 6
if j and k are not coprime, dp[i][j][k] = 0
else, dp[i][j][k] = summation(dp[i-1][k][l]) where l is in range [1,6] AND l!=j and j!=k
# this ensures a min gap of 3 and maintains co-primality of adjacent numberssum(dp[N][1..6])这具有O(N*6*6) ~ O(N)的时间和空间复杂性。
编辑:@KellyBundy很好地添加了Python实现;纠正了它(以及我的回答中的一个小缺陷),并在这里添加:
def count_seq(N):
A = range(1, 7)
dp = [[[None] * 7 for _ in range(7)] for _ in range(N+1)]
for j in A:
for k in A:
dp[0][j][k] = 0
dp[1][j][k] = 0
dp[2][j][k] = int(gcd(j,k)==1 and j!=k)
for i in range(3, N+1):
for j in A:
for k in A:
if gcd(j, k) != 1:
dp[i][j][k] = 0
else:
dp[i][j][k] = sum(dp[i-1][k][l] for l in A if (l!=j and j!=k))
return sum(dp[N][j][k] for j in A for k in A)
N = 100
print(count_seq(N))发布于 2022-04-07 07:32:25
这里有一个图搜索问题,它可以通过回溯搜索来解决,并且可以使用回忆录使其运行得更快。
定义州
按照问题中的规则,状态是元组,其中元组中的第一个值是当前数a_n,而序列a_{n-1}中的前一个数是序列的长度,因为数字的出现可以在2或更长的区间内。
此外,禁止状态是两个数不是共素数的状态,这意味着
number_set = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]长度为2的是一个有效状态,但禁用集除外,即:
forbidden_tuples = {(2,4), (2,6), (4,6), (3,6), (4,2), (6,2), (6,4), (6,3)}示例:((2,3), 5)处于状态( 2,3 ),所需的序列长度为5。在这种情况下,下列数字不能是2,3(保持至少2的距离)或6(保持相邻数的余素数),因此后续状态的总数为:
建立解决方案
我将提供的解决方案是一个递归的DFE图和回忆录的时间优化。解决办法如下:
import itertools
def count_seq(N, start_state=None, memoization=None):
"""
:param N:
:param start_state
:param memoization
:return: Rules:
1. a_i in {1,2,3,4,5,6}
2. Two adjacent numbers should be coprime. For e.g. 2,4,.. sequence is not allowed ( for the set {1,2,3,4,5,6} this means that (2,6),(2,4),(3,6),(4,6) are forbidden
3. repetitions with a distance >= 2
State are ordered as a 2 item tuple to remember the history: (a_{n-1} , a_n)
"""
if N == 1:
return 6
if memoization is None:
memoization = {}
count = 0
state_set = set() # Pending states which have not been explored yet
number_set = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]
forbidden_tuples = {(2,4), (2,6), (4,6), (3,6), (4,2), (6,2), (6,4), (6,3)}
if start_state is None: # Getting initial states
for subset in itertools.permutations(number_set, 2):
if subset in forbidden_tuples:
pass
else:
state_set.add((subset, N))
else: # checking all possible next states and appending to queue with 1 less length
for ii in number_set:
if ii in start_state or (ii, start_state[-1]) in forbidden_tuples:
pass
else:
state_set.add(((start_state[1:] + tuple([ii])), N-1))
# for each possible next state
for state in state_set:
if state[1] <= 2:
count += 1
elif state in memoization: # checking if we computed this already
count += memoization[state]
else: #we did not compute this, doing the computation
memoization[state] = count_seq(state[1], state[0], memoization)
count += memoization[state]
return count探索
如果想要的长度为1,请返回6,因为这两个数字中的任何一个都可以位于第一个位置。
None,我们假设这是初始调用,所以我们创建了长度为2的数字的所有可能的无禁止排列。否则,我们创建一组所有可能的下一个状态。memoization字典中计算了此状态。如果我们这样做了,我们从字典中提取计数值并使用它,否则我们会用起始状态和想要的序列长度递归地调用这个函数。计时
当运行此函数时禁用回忆录,我们将获得N=200
%timeit count_seq_slow(200)
199 ms ± 9.63 ms per loop (mean ± std. dev. of 7 runs, 1 loop each)
%timeit count_seq(200)
13.6 ms ± 833 µs per loop (mean ± std. dev. of 7 runs, 100 loops each)当增加到N=2000时,我们得到:
%timeit count_seq_slow(2000)
3.54 s ± 374 ms per loop (mean ± std. dev. of 7 runs, 1 loop each)
%timeit count_seq(2000)
147 ms ± 7.02 ms per loop (mean ± std. dev. of 7 runs, 10 loops each)发布于 2022-04-07 07:53:22
设K[n, d1, d2]是长度为n的有效序列数,如果d1,d2出现在前面,则序列仍然有效。或等效地,以d1,d2开头的长度为d1的有效序列的数目。
有一个K满足的递归关系:
K[n, d1, d2] = 0 if d1=d2 or d1 is not coprime to d2.
K[0, d1, d2] = 1
K[n, d1, d2] = sum(K[n-1, d2, d] for d=1..6 - {d1, d2})这个K可以使用自下而上的动态程序或回忆录来计算.
对于n>=2,可以使用以下方法解决最初的问题:
S[n] = sum(K[n-2, d1, d2] for d1=1..6, d2=1..6)对于n<=2,我们有S[0] = 1和S[1] = 6。
使用O(1)空间和O(n)时间编写这段代码的一种方法是:
from math import gcd
def S(n):
if n == 0: return 1
if n == 1: return 6
K = [d1!=d2 and gcd(d1+1, d2+1)==1 for d1 in range(6) for d2 in range(6)]
for _ in range(n-2):
K = [0 if d1==d2 or gcd(d1+1, d2+1)!=1 else sum(K[d2*6+d] for d in range(6) if d!= d1 and d!=d2) for d1 in range(6) for d2 in range(6)]
return sum(K)这将迭代地从K[n,_,_]中计算K[n-1,_,_]。
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/71776343
复制相似问题